Comparison Flux-Hi™

Flooded Evaporator

Plateheatexchanger


 

Task:

Capacity: 2040kW

Media 1: Ammonia (NH3) t0:-8°C

Media 2: Carbon-Dioxid (CO2) tc:-5°C

The Ammonia shall evaporate completely, the liquid Ammonia shall be separated in a gravity separator. Additonaly to the Capacity of 2040kW a sideload of 500kW coming from a glycolcooler shall be separated. The CO2 shall condensate completely.

Solution 1: Flooded Evaporator

Size: BXM1400/6000/1

Separator: integrated in Evaporator, no additional vessel needed

Execution: openable, repairs easy possible

Receiver: no additional receiver needed, Ammonia System-Filling can be stored in Evaporator

Solution 2: Plateheatexchanger

Size: 14

Separator: additional Separator needed

Execution: welded, Revisions not possible

Receiver: needed, Ammonia filling can not be stored in heatexchanger

Solution 3: Flux-Hi™

Size: CAS11-6

Separator: integrated in Evaporator, no additional vessel needed

Execution: openable, repairs easy possible

Receiver: no additional receiver needed, Ammonia System-Filling can be stored in Evaporator

Overview:

Criteria

Flux-HI™

Flooded Evaporator

Plateheatexchanger

Price

++

+

-

Repairs

++

++

-

Size

+

+

+

effectiveness 

++

-

+